Responsibility Of Intermediary Service Provider For Defective Products Purchased Electronically. 06 February 2022
ON 15.11.2021, REGARDING THE LIABILITY OF THE SERVICE PROVIDER, 3rd LEGAL DEPARTMENT OF HIGH COURT DECIDED THAT THE INTERMEDIATE SERVICE PROVIDER IS NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR THE DEFICIENCY OF THE PRODUCTS WHICH ARE PURCHASED ELECTRONICALLY.

1. According to Article 2 of the Law on the Regulation of Electronical Commerce, which came into force on 01.05.2015, with the headline "Definitions" states that; service provider means 'Real or legal persons engaged in electronic commerce activities', intermediary service provider means 'real and legal persons who provide the electronic commerce environment for the economic and commercial activities of others'. In the decision, which is based on the examination of the responsibility attributed to real and legal persons defined within the scope of this law, after the purchasing of the product from the intermediary service provider's website the package was sent to the buyer by a registered "patisserie" of the site. Following the delivery, it was discovered that a cigarette butt came out from the package and accordingly, the responsibility for the defective product was examined. |
Today, it is obvious that commercial and daily life is gradually shifting towards the virtual environment. At this point, classifying the responsibility attributed for the products purchased over internet has become a difficult issue to dissect. In line with the developments, the work of legislators and related institutions carries crucial importance. The relevant event, which is the subject of our bulletin, has become even more critical due to the direction of today's understanding of consumption. |
In the concrete case, the plaintiff, who objected to the decision of the Esenler Consumer Arbitration Committee, stated that they have only mediated through the website where the plaintiff offered services to real or legal persons conducting sales activities. The defendant's application for a refund due to the defective product was accepted by the Consumer Arbitration Committee with the decision dated 20.03.2019 and numbered 056120190000723. The request of the intermediary institution, which objected to the decision regarding the refund, was rejected by the court of first degree. The reason for the refusal arises from the fact that the buyer receives service by relying on the name of the intermediary service provider. In the decision, the court further stated the basis for the refusal as the internal relationship between the plaintiff and the company providing the supply, thus, the issue of recourse is also not applicable since this relationship is subject to the internal affairs of the intermediary and the supplier. |
Following this, in the letter of the Ministry of Justice dated 17/03/2021; Although it is not possible to deal with the liability of the plaintiff company, which is not a seller, importer or manufacturer, but is a service provider to the consumer, in accordance with Articles 8 and the following, with the title of "Defective Goods" in the First Chapter of the Third Part of the Law on the Protection of the Consumer, It has been argued that the dismissal of the lawsuit on the grounds that the company is responsible for the services rendered due to commission received from the supplier company is contrary to the procedure and the law. |
All of the above-mentioned materials were evaluated by the High Court. The Court analyzed the issue that caused the dispute as the liability regarding the defect in the products purchased electronically and started its examinations accordingly. |
Evaluating the issue, the High Court first made analyzes within the framework of Article 13 of the Law on the Protection of the Consumer. According to the first paragraph of the relevant article, “Defective service is a service that is contrary to the contract because it does not start within the time specified in the contract or does not have the features that are agreed by the parties that it should have objectively.” Again, in accordance with Article 11 of the same Law, the responsibility of the seller, the manufacturer and the importer for the defective goods and the responsibility of the consumer for the optional rights are stated in this article. |
According to Article 2 of the Law on the Regulation of Electronic Commerce, which entered into force on 01.05.2015, in the title "Definitions", service provider means; 'Real or legal persons engaged in electronic commerce'. The intermediary service provider, which is defined in the continuation of the article, refers to the real and legal persons who provide the electronic commerce environment for the economic and commercial activities of others. |
Responsibility of Intermediary Service Providers, defined in Article 9 of the same law, is also stated in paragraph 4 of Article 6 of the same law as; “(4) The intermediary service provider is not obliged to check the content provided by real and legal persons using the electronic environment it provides services through, or to investigate whether there is an unlawful activity or situation related to this content and the goods or services subject to the content.” |
With this approach of the High Court, the responsibility automatically attributed to institutions that only act as intermediaries, and the obligation of recourse that arises accordingly, has been eliminated and a more direct causal link has been established between the parties. Thus, the 6th and 9th articles of the Law on the Regulation of Electronic Commerce were evaluated together and considering that the plaintiff, who is the intermediary service provider, is not responsible for the defective goods, a verdict has to be given for the acceptance of the case. The appeal request of the Ministry of Justice advocating regarding this aspect of the law has been accepted. |
As a result, with the decision taken, the approach of the Consumer Arbitration Committee, which holds the intermediary institutions directly responsible, was found to be faulty and the foundations for a more balanced regime between the Consumer and the Intermediary Institution were laid. Thanks to this approach of the Court of Cassation, institutions and organizations that carry out intermediary activities by receiving commissions on their own website are evaluated according to strict liability before the Arbitration Committees, and with this decision, the responsibility of the intermediary has been reduced and the responsibility relationship between the parties has been classified more clearly. |
Other News
-
2.1.2023
What Are The New Determinations Under Article 1530 Of The Turkish Commercial Code ?
In the Official Gazette numbered 32061 published on 02.01.2023, the Central Bank of the Republic of Turkey announced the Communiqué on the Default Interest Rate to be aplied for Late Payments in the Supply of Goods and Services and the Minimum Expense Amount that can be claimed for the Collection Costs of Receivables ("Communiqué").
-
2.1.2023
Interest Rates To Be Applied In Rediscount And Advance Transactions Were Determined.
On 31 December 2022, new rates were announced by the Central Bank of the Republic of Turkey with the Communiqué on Determination of Interest Rates to be applied in Rediscount and Advance Transactions in the Official Gazette numbered 32060.
-
28.12.2022
Top 10 Deals Of The Year 2022
-
19.12.2022
What Are Increasing Monetary Limits And Changing
1- Law On Consumer Protection Monetary Limits In The Regulation On Consumer Arbitration Committees Increased In the Official Gazette dated 16 December 2022 and numbered 32045; 68 of the Law on the Protection of the Consumer No. 502 and Article 6 of the Regulation on Consumer Arbitration Committees ("Communiqué") on Increasing the Monetary Limits has been published and entered into force.
-
6.12.2022
Chain Stores in the Food Retail Sector Are Obliged to Share Data.
The Regulation on Amending the Regulation on the Principles and Rules to be Applied in Retail Trade (hereinafter referred to as "Regulation") has been published and entered into force.
-
5.12.2022
Will "Obligation To Obtain And Submit A Surveyor's Report'' To Be Introduced In Real Estate Sales?
On 25 October 2022, the "Presidential Annual Program for 2023" (hereinafter referred to as the "Program") prepared by the Ministry of Treasury and Finance and the Presidency of Strategy and Budget with the Presidential Decree No. 6294 was announced in the Official Gazette repeating No. 31994.
-
4.12.2022
What Are The Changes Introduced by the Decision Regarding The Determination Of The Companies Subject To Independent Audit?
As it is known, the independent audit, which is important in terms of informing both the public and the shareholders about the financial status of the company, is obligatory for companies to be determined by the President in accordance with the Turkish Commercial Code (TCC) No. 6102.
-
14.9.2022
What Are The Provisions That Have Been Postdated In The Distance Contracts Regulation?
The "REGULATION ON AMENDING THE REGULATION ON THE REGULATION ON DISTANCE CONTRACTS" (Hereinafter referred to as "Regulation") was published in the Official Gazette dated 14 September 2022, and in accordance with this Regulation, the effective dates of some regulations made on August 23, 2022 have been amended.
-
17.7.2022
Alterations in the Context of the Law on the Regulation of Electronic Commerce
In consequence of the amendments made in the Law No. 6563 ("Law") with the Law No. 7416 on the Amendment of the Law on the Regulation of Electronic Commerce, published in the Official Gazette dated 7 July 2022 and numbered 31889, numerous new legal regulations have been envisaged on issues such as the obligations of electronic commerce intermediary service providers ("Intermediary Service Providers") and electronic commerce service providers ("Service Providers"), the administrative fines foreseen in case of violation of these obligations, the electronic commerce license and the expansion of the powers of the Ministry of Commerce ("Ministry") in this area. In this article, the contents of the provisions of the relevant Law will be cited and the date of entry into force will be explained as a consequence of the new regulations envisaged.
-
29.6.2022
THE OFFICIAL GAZETTE HAS PUBLISHED THE REGULATION AUTHORIZING THE SALE OF IMMOVABLES BY THE NOTARY, WITH THE EFFECTIVE DATE SET FOR JANUARY 1, 2023.
With the "Law on the Amendment of the Law on Judges and Prosecutors and Some Other Legislation" numbered 7413 published in the Official Gazette dated 28 June 2022, a regulation authorizing the sale of real estate to notaries was introduced.
-
1.6.2022
Obligation to Provide Continuous Information Regarding Advertisements Posted on the Internet
The Tax Procedure Law General Communiqué with line number 538 published in the Official Gazette dated 31 May 2022 has been published. Within the scope of this Communiqué, certain obligations were imposed on intermediary service providers, social network providers and hosting providers that mediate the publication of advertisements for the purchase, sale or rental of movable and real properties and goods and services. Aforementioned persons are obliged to report certain information specified in the Communiqué regarding the transactions they carry out to the Turkish Revenue Administration through the system created in the electronic environment.
-
25.4.2022
Constitutional Court Decision On Fingerprint Registration System Is Published!
The Constitutional Court made a new decision regarding tracking employees' shifts by the employers in the working life, with fingerprint, face, palm, or retina scanning methods. The decision of the Constitutional Court, dated 10.03.2022, stating that tracking employees' shift with the fingerprint registration system violates the right to protection of personal data, was published in the Official Gazette dated 19 april 2022 and numbered 31814.
-
24.4.2022
The Application Necessity Of Mediator In Negative Declaratory Actions!
The issue of the application necessity of mediator in terms of negative declaratory actions has been a matter of debate in doctrines and case-laws. However, at this point, a consensus has been reached on this issue and it is accepted that there is no application necessity of mediator in terms of negative declaratory actions.
-
19.4.2022
Amendment To The Currency Of Payment To Be Made In Foreign Exchange Indexed Sale Of Goods Contracts!
In accordance with the Decision No. 32 on the Protection of the Value of the Turkish Currency, the matters to be determined by the Ministry of Treasury and Finance are regulated by the "COMMUNIQUE REGARDING DECISION NO. 32 ON THE PROTECTION OF THE VALUE OF TURKISH CURRENCY (“the Communiqué”) (Communiqué No: 2008-32/34)".
-
18.4.2022
Charging Service Regulation Regarding Electric Vehicles Is Published!
In the context of the Charging Service Regulation (“Regulation”), published in the Official Gazette dated 02.04.2022 and numbered 31797, which entered into force on the date of its publication, the procedures and principles regarding the establishment of charging units and stations where electrical energy is supplied to electric vehicles, administration of stations connected to the charging network, provisions of charging service are determined. In this study, the main principles envisaged by the Regulation will be reviewed.